• FableSpark Newsletter
  • Posts
  • Skittles or M&Ms? Cialdini, Kant, and Jesus on Sparking Curiosity to Light a Movement

Skittles or M&Ms? Cialdini, Kant, and Jesus on Sparking Curiosity to Light a Movement

A tool so potent for marketing and sales that you MUST apply a 3000-year-old rule or chance turning to the dark side

Imagine a tool so potent in the arsenal of persuasion that its mere application can render your audience captive, hanging onto your every word, and waiting with bated breath for the next revelation. That tool, dear reader, is curiosity.

I’ll start by asking you a simple question:

“Which do you like better, Skittles or M&M’s?”

You’ll understand why this is important once you get deeper into the newsletter…

But first, let's delve deeper into the psyche of your audience using renowned psychologist and author Robert Cialdini's insights. Specifically, we’ll be carving Curiosity down to it’s core, and we should remember it’s as old as human existence itself.

All men by nature desire to know.

Aristotle

Whether it's the child who asks endless 'why' questions or adults seeking knowledge, it's a primal instinct. In the realm of marketing and sales, this instinct can be the gateway to compelling narratives and engaging content.

We will be covering five ways in which curiosity can be harnessed to help hook your prospects and compel them to take actions that are good for both them and for your bottom line.

1. Information Gap Theory:

Plato suggested, "Knowledge which is acquired under compulsion obtains no hold on the mind." 

When you provide a hint or a teaser, you're not forcing information. Instead, you're creating a void, and nature abhors a vacuum. The audience feels compelled to fill this void — to close the gap between what they know and what they could know.

This is the heart of George Loewenstein's "Information Gap Theory," and Cialdini champions it as a persuasive strategy.

Information Gap Theory in Action

Loewenstein postulates that when there's a gap between what we know and what we want to know, it creates a feeling of deprivation. This gap ignites our curiosity, prompting us to take action to bridge the divide. In essence, we feel an intrinsic drive to seek out the missing information and attain a state of cognitive completeness.

Bridging the Divide (Crafted with MidJourney)

Applications in Marketing:

  1. Teasers & Pre-launch Campaigns: Ever noticed movie trailers that leave you with cliffhangers? Or product teasers that give just a glimpse without revealing the whole product? These strategies are classic examples of exploiting the information gap. By providing just enough information to intrigue but not satisfy, marketers create a strong desire in potential customers to seek out the full story or product upon its release.

  2. Content Marketing: Click-worthy headlines often use the information gap. Titles like "5 Things Successful People Do Before 8 AM" or "The Secret Ingredient to Perfect Pancakes" spark interest because they hint at information the reader might not possess but would likely want.

Applications in Sales:

  1. Product Demonstrations: Effective salespeople often start by showcasing a problem the audience might not even know they have. Once the problem is established, the salesperson refrains from immediately giving the solution, creating an information gap. As the demo progresses, this gap becomes more pronounced until the product or service is revealed as the solution, making its introduction deeply satisfying and convincing.

  2. Consultative Selling: In this approach, a salesperson acts more as a consultant than a traditional seller. They ask probing questions to understand the client's needs, challenges, or aspirations. By making the client aware of certain gaps in their current strategy or approach (that the product or service can address), the salesperson creates an information gap that makes their offering more appealing.

To wrap up our first concept, Loewenstein's Information Gap Theory is a powerful tool in the arsenal of marketers and sales professionals. By understanding and harnessing the human drive for cognitive completeness, they can create campaigns and strategies that naturally draw consumers in, making them eager to learn more, engage, or purchase.

2. Sparking Curiosity:

Remember when Socrates said, "I know that I am intelligent because I know that I know nothing?"

Sparking Curiosity (Crafted with MidJourney)

By presenting something unknown or mysterious related to your content, you ignite that intrinsic desire to know more. Those intriguing questions are the modern-day Socratic method in action, pushing the audience to seek answers.

3. Maintaining Engagement:

As Sun Tzu said in The Art of War, "Opportunities multiply as they are seized." 

When you have your audience's attention, don't let it wane. Weave a tale, dribble out the information, and keep them on their toes. People thrive on narratives; it's why we've been telling stories since the dawn of time.

4. Cognitive Dissonance:

Now, here's a contrarian view. When you challenge someone's preconceived beliefs or introduce a fact that creates discomfort, it might seem like a deterrent. But, as Friedrich Nietzsche once mentioned, "You have your way. I have my way. As for the right way, the correct way, and the only way, it does not exist."

Cognitive dissonance, though unsettling, stimulates curiosity. It's a way to make your audience rethink and be more receptive to your message.

Imagine This Scenario:

You have two favorite candies — let's say, Skittles and M&Ms. One day, your friend offers you a pack of each and says you can only pick one. You choose Skittles, but as you start to eat them, you start thinking about how much you also love M&Ms. Suddenly, you're not so sure about your choice, and you feel a little uneasy or weird. Why? Because you love both, but you had to pick one.

That Uneasy Feeling? That's cognitive dissonance.

Which Box, Which Candy? Choose Only One! (Crafted with MidJourney)

Breaking It Down:

"Cognitive" means related to thinking or our thoughts. "Dissonance" is like a clash or conflict. So, cognitive dissonance is when we have conflicting feelings or beliefs about something.

It's like when you know junk food isn't super healthy, but you really want that slice of pizza. Your brain says, "Wait a minute! This doesn't add up!" On one hand, you want to eat healthily, but on the other hand, pizza is delicious! That inner conflict, where you're trying to make sense of two opposing thoughts, is cognitive dissonance.

Why Does It Matter?

We all want our thoughts and actions to line up. It makes us feel consistent and balanced. When they don't match, our brain tries to fix it. Maybe you justify eating the pizza by telling yourself, "Well, I'll eat a salad tomorrow," or "One slice won’t hurt." That’s your brain trying to ease the discomfort of cognitive dissonance.

In Short:

Cognitive dissonance is like your mind's way of saying, "Hey! These two things don't quite fit together. Let's figure it out!" And while it can feel confusing at times, it's a totally normal part of growing and understanding ourselves better.

Remember, it's okay to engender these feelings. They help us learn, make decisions, and even change our minds about things. Just like deciding which candy or snack is the best! 😉🍬🍕

Let's delve into some ways cognitive dissonance can be harnessed in marketing and sales:

Marketing Examples:

  1. Eco-friendly Products: Advertise a beautiful plastic bottle with the tagline, "Isn't it gorgeous? But it'll be in the landfill for the next 500 years." This creates a conflict in the viewer's mind between the aesthetic appeal of the product and its environmental impact, pushing them towards eco-friendly alternatives.

  2. Health Campaigns: Show a picture of a mouth-watering burger next to a less appealing salad with the line, "What your taste buds want vs. what your heart needs." The juxtaposition creates dissonance between immediate gratification and long-term health, nudging people to make healthier choices.

Sales Examples:

  1. Tech Upgrade: If a customer is looking at a new smartphone, a salesperson might say, "It's impressive how you've managed with your old phone for so long, especially when this new one is ten times faster and can do so much more." This creates a tension between the customer's current status and the potential benefits of upgrading.

  2. Clothing Sales: "That dress looks stunning on you. It's surprising it’s still in stock, given how popular this design has been." By suggesting the item is in-demand, the salesperson creates dissonance in the customer's mind: 'If everyone else recognizes its value and I don't buy it now, am I missing out?'

Remember, the key with cognitive dissonance in marketing and sales is to strike a delicate balance. Overdoing it can lead to customers feeling manipulated, while the right amount can effectively encourage a desired behavior or decision.

And that naturally leads us to…

5. Ethical Considerations:

We all know the Golden Rule, and for good reason. It’s about as basic and yet profound as anything anyone has ever said or written down.

The common English phrasing is "Do unto others as you would have them do unto you".

Ancient Golden Rule(r) (Crafted with MidJourney)

One of the earliest statements of the golden rule is found in the Hindu Upanishads (800–600 BC): “Let no man do to another that which would be repugnant to himself; this is the sum of righteousness; the rest is according to inclination”.

Rushworth Kidder identifies the concept as appearing prominently in Confucianism (551–479 BCE), Buddhism, Christianity, Hinduism, Islam, Judaism, Taoism, Zoroastrianism, and "the rest of the world's major religions".

As part of the 1993 "Declaration Toward a Global Ethic", 143 leaders of the world's major faiths endorsed the Golden Rule.

If, however, Reason is your guiding light rather than religion, you’ll likely align with Immanuel Kant (see Roger Scruton’s “Kant: A Very Short Introduction”).

"Act in such a way that you treat humanity, whether in your own person or in the person of any other, never merely as a means to an end, but always at the same time as an end."

Immanuel Kant

I’ll give an example that might help us apply this in real world situations…

If a surgeon harvesting vital organs from an unwilling, live “donor” would maximize the good, for instance, by preserving the lives of five people desperate for transplants, he would be treating the donor merely as a means and thereby crossing a basic, some would say sacrosanct moral line.

The operative word here and in the quote above is “merely”, which goes to show how changing merely one word in a statement, in your headline, in a hook, etc. can drastically affect the overall power and meaning you wish to convey.

The ethical use of curiosity aligns with principles of respect for individuals and their right to make informed decisions. It also underscores the idea that persuasion should be based on genuine value and not on deceptive tactics.

No matter from what culture or the exact phrasing, the Golden Rule is a solid reminder that while curiosity is an effective tool, it must be applied with moral integrity.

Curiosity: A Multi-tool in your persuasion toolbox

The amalgamation of Cialdini's research and philosophy gives rise to a powerful narrative for your business. Curiosity is but one concept in his persuasion toolbox. See my article below for an overview of Cialdini’s tenets on Persuasion.

Use these tools to make your content an ever-unfolding tale of intrigue, wrapped in layers of genuine value and ethical considerations.

In your business you can apply Cialdini's insights to create compelling content that engages curiosity, keeps your audience engaged, and ultimately leads to the desired actions, whether it's consuming your media or purchasing your products.

Remember, curiosity is a powerful tool, but it should be wielded responsibly and ethically to build trust and long-term relationships with your audience.

The ball is in your court now. Equip your businesses with these principles of curiosity, craft magnetic narratives, and witness the magic unfold as your audience gravitates toward your offerings. Harness curiosity ethically, provide value, both up front before getting paid and after, and you and your clients will prosper together.

Call To Action

Please Subscribe to this newsletter and share it on your favorite social media platform so more people can learn the life essentials no one teaches us in school.

And to slate your own curiosity, check out Robert Cialdini’s book "Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion," where he explores the concept of curiosity and how it can be harnessed for effective persuasion for your business or your movement.